10 Stars Originally Considered for Knockout Roles - Raindance

These celebrities were supposed to play roles that soon became iconic. Hard to imagine anyone else playing the roles that came to be so widely recognized.  This shows how much of an impact good casting has on a film.

1      Gwyneth Paltrow –Rose in Titanic

Gwyneth rejected the role because she wasn’t that interested in the script. At the time Kate Winslet was less well known than Gwen. Turning down the role turned out for the best, because I’m sure no one could have topped Kate’s portrayal of Rose.

2      Eric Stoltz- Marty McFly in Back to the Future

Spielberg originally favored Stoltz to play Marty McFly. However, after a screen test studios decided he took the role too seriously and wasn’t comedic enough.

3      Molly Ringwald- Vivian in Pretty Women

Molly was supposed to play the role of Vivian in Pretty Women, which soon went to Julian Roberts. She turned down the role, which was a big mistake on her part. If she took it, maybe her career would have continued to flourish past her golden era of the ‘80s.

4      John Travolta- Forrest Gump

Travolta passed up the role, later realizing it was a mistake.  John missed out, but let’s be honest, can you really imagine Travolta delivering the line “Life is like a box of chocolates”?

5      Robin Williams- Jack in The Shining

Though Robin Williams has played a psychopath in thrillers One Hour Photo and Insomnia, he still may have been a little too goofy to play Jack, (Mrs. Doubtfire gone wild, anyone?) Stephen King actually was the one who talked Kubrick out of casting him.

6      Sarah Michelle Gellar- Cher in Clueless

Though Sarah Michelle Gellar has plenty experience playing a sassy teen in TV series Buffy the Vampire Slayer, she turned down the role due to scheduling conflicts with All My Children. As if!

7      Matthew McConaughey – Jack in Titanic

Even though studios were considering McConaughey, James Cameron had a strong preference for Leonardo DiCaprio to play Jack. Good choice Cameron.

8      Colin Farrell – James bond in Casino Royale

Colin selflessly chose not to take on the part. He believed the role should be offered to someone not as widely known. He thought people would just compare him to his past roles and it would take a bit of mystery out of the James Bond character.

9      Jim Carrey- Captain Jack sparrow in Pirates of the Caribbean

He was offered the role of legendary Captain Jack Sparrow but had to turn it down because it conflicted with the shooting of Bruce Almighty. Even though Jim Carrey posses that eccentric charm necessary for Captain Jack, his performance may have been too over the top.

10  Leonardo DiCaprio- Patrick Bateman in American Psycho

At the time when DiCaprio was in the running of becoming Patrick Batemen, this golden boy was still relishing in the success of Titanic. His fanbase included a lot of young girls and being in such a racy movie like American Psycho would have brought the wrong audience along.



Don’t let casting directors go unappreciated…